Advice

Timber framer or steel erector: which is the best career change?

Techtime7 min read

Carpenter wearing ear defenders cutting a piece with a circular saw on a timber frame

Please note: this article refers to French regulations and standards.

Whether working with timber or metal, carpentry is one of the construction trades most in need of qualified candidates. The labour shortage is such that 83% of French construction companies struggle to recruit, according to a survey by France Travail, then called Pôle Emploi (source). Although the main task remains the same (erecting a building’s structural frame), these professionals specialise in a specific material. Timber framer or steel erector: what are the differences between these two specialities?

In brief

The timber framer and the steel erector both erect building frames, but differ in their material, tools and worksites. The former works mainly for craft businesses, on detached houses and chalets; the latter for industrial firms and public works, on industrial and commercial buildings and civil engineering structures. Salaries and career paths are similar: in France, from the minimum wage (SMIC) at the start of a career to €26,000 gross a year or more after 10 years’ experience.

1Strong, eco-friendly materials, but with different weaknesses

Originally, carpenters worked with timber to build the frames of houses, bridges, monuments and even ships. During the Industrial Revolution, iron and other metals became increasingly common in architecture thanks to the development of the steel industry. What are the differences between these two materials?

Timber: the material for traditional roof structures

Timber is the raw material of choice for building a traditional roof structure or a glulam structure. It is mainly softwood (fir, spruce, Douglas fir, larch), as these trees are strong and plentiful. The carpenter uses them to make long timber members with different cross-sections. Hardwoods (oak, beech, ash, etc.) are used more for joinery or cabinetmaking components: half-timbering, staircases, dormers, parquet, etc. (source).

As well as being strong and readily available, timber is attractive and easy to work. It is a good thermal insulator and a good sound insulator. However, it needs chemical treatment against damp to prevent fungi or insects. Despite its strength, a timber frame does not withstand fire for long.

Metal: the material for industrial structures

Metal (steel, aluminium or stainless steel) forms the beams of modern constructions and large-scale buildings, such as factories or shopping centres. These benefit from lightness and a long span (up to 40 m (source)), essential for building a flat roof. Steel components are also economical, recyclable and quicker to assemble than timber ones, with time savings estimated at 30% (source).

However, only a specialist can design a bespoke steel structure, as it requires very precise calculations. Steel is a poor insulator and must undergo several protective treatments against fire or rust.

2Specific techniques and tools for assembling the structure

Carpenters use various tools to cut, drill, sand or assemble the members of their structure. These tools are specific to the material they work with. The basic steps for building a frame remain the same: calculating dimensions, workshop assembly and erection on site following the full-size layout. However, jointing techniques differ between a timber frame and a steel frame.

Diagram The steps common to every roof structure
  1. 1Calculatethe dimensions
  2. 2Assemblein the workshop
  3. 3Erecton site, following the full-size layout

Tools and techniques for working a timber frame

A timber framer works with various sets of traditional tools (source) to cut beams carefully and precisely. Besides wood saws and different types of hammer, they use a twibill to cut tenons and mortises. The drawknife removes bark from the wood, while the adze is used to rough it out.

A timber frame can be built using several methods:

  • joints without metal connectors, with male and female parts (mortise and tenon, dovetail, birdsmouth, etc.);
  • modern joints with metal connectors in the form of bolts, screws or nails (joist hangers, reinforced angle brackets, perforated plates). These are used for specific members such as purlins, rafters or battens.

Tools and techniques for working a steel frame

The steel erector’s tools are designed for maximum speed and precision. Some are powered, such as the band saw, sander, angle grinder, torque-adjustable screwdriver or electric shears. Others are manual, such as the press brake, shears or clamps.

A steel frame is first assembled on the ground, following the full-size layout, before being lifted into place with construction machinery (crane, aerial work platform). Beams and other metal parts are joined by welding, bolts or rivets.

3Timber framer or steel erector: distinct skills

According to the job profiles of Onisep (France’s careers information service), all carpenters share common skills. They must master geometry and calculation to produce or study technical drawings. If these are produced with BIM, some computer skills are also needed. They can recognise and choose the right materials for a specific part of the structure. Outdoor work requires great physical stamina, especially given possible exposure to bad weather. Carpenters may work in a team or independently, while remaining flexible and ready to travel long distances. Finally, they must be rigorous in their movements and in applying safety rules.

However, timber framers and steel erectors do not follow the same training. Their courses differ on the following main points:

  • mastery of the tools, machinery and techniques mentioned above;
  • knowledge of their respective materials (properties and uses by type of construction);
  • knowledge of structural treatments (against damp for timber, against corrosion for metal);
  • secondary tasks (joinery or cabinetmaking for timber framers; metalwork or industrial painting for steel erectors).

4Very different clients for construction projects

Carpenters must be able to work on any worksite, whether residential or industrial. In reality, the clients who call on their services differ according to their speciality.

Timber framers mainly work on building or renovating detached houses or chalets. These projects reflect growing interest in eco-friendly homes, under French law no. 2015-992 on the energy transition (source).

Timber professionals may also work on industrial buildings, agricultural or commercial ones if they have a glulam structure. But generally, these large flat-roofed buildings are topped with a steel frame. Steel erectors also work on civil engineering structures such as bridges, footbridges, pylons, etc.

5Different working conditions for erecting the building’s structure

Carpenters work both in the workshop and outdoors on site. Their physical stamina must be excellent to handle heavy loads or hold uncomfortable positions for hours. Working on scaffolding several dozen metres high, a good carpenter is not put off by vertigo.

Timber framers are more likely to work for a craft business. Off-site work is possible thanks to cutting timber beams in the workshop. Although sheltered from the weather in these conditions, they must wear the necessary equipment to protect themselves from wood dust (potentially carcinogenic).

Steel erectors are employed by more industrial construction firms or in public works (source). Because of the larger size of the buildings, they spend more time outdoors whatever the weather. Metal parts are also harder to prefabricate, especially for large structures. Much of the assembly and adjustment is done directly on site.

6Similar salaries and career paths for carpenters

A beginner carpenter in France starts on the minimum wage (SMIC). With 10 years’ experience, their gross annual salary can reach or exceed €26,000 (source). Note that pay can vary by region: the Île-de-France region pays better than the rest of France because the cost of living is higher.

With seniority, a timber framer or steel erector can be promoted to team leader or trainer. They can also choose to set up their own business.

Diagram Timber framer or steel erector?
Timber framerSoftwood, glulam
  • Detached houses and chalets
  • Craft businesses
  • Beams cut in the workshop
Steel erectorSteel, aluminium, stainless steel
  • Industrial buildings and civil engineering structures
  • Industrial firms and public works
  • Mostly assembled on site

Want to become a timber framer or a steel erector? Beyond the materials, remember that you won’t use the same tools or work on the same construction projects. And the workshop/site ratio depends on your speciality. If you still have any doubts, particularly about starting a business, don’t hesitate to contact our experts in supporting business owners.

Want to discover other construction trades? Become a site manager, for example.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a timber framer and a steel erector?

The timber framer builds structures in softwood or glulam, with beams often cut in the workshop. The steel erector works with steel, aluminium or stainless steel for large structures, mostly assembled on site by welding, bolts or rivets.

How much does a carpenter earn?

In France, a beginner carpenter is paid the minimum wage (SMIC). With 10 years’ experience, their gross annual salary can reach or exceed €26,000. The Île-de-France region pays better than the rest of France.

What skills do you need to become a carpenter?

All carpenters must master geometry and calculation to produce or study technical drawings, know how to choose materials, have great physical stamina for outdoor work and apply safety rules rigorously.

Free trial

Sign up in under 47 seconds

No commitment, and you gain your superpowers: 14 days to try Techtime with your teams.

Yes, I’m flying: sign me up
Illustration: three people in superhero capes on a building under construction, between two cranes